Understanding Encroachment: Impact on Property Ownership and Rights

Estimated reading time: 8 minutes

Land and property encroachment is a pervasive issue in India, affecting property owners across urban and rural landscapes alike. Whether you’re an NRI owning property back home or a resident managing assets within the country, understanding encroachment and knowing how to address it is crucial.

This blog delves into the intricacies of property encroachment in India, outlining legal definitions, remedies, and preventive measures to safeguard your investments.

What is Encroachment?

Encroachment in real estate refers to the illegal use or invasion of someone else’s property without permission. According to Section 441 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860, encroachment happens when a person trespasses onto another person’s land or property. This can include building structures on someone else’s land or using their property in a way that threatens or insults the owner.

---

Types of Encroachment in Real Estate

There are two main types of encroachment:

1. Land Encroachment:

This happens when someone takes over or uses another person’s land without permission. For example, imagine Mr. Raj buys a piece of land but doesn’t build anything on it. Later, he discovers that someone has started farming on his land without his approval. This situation is land encroachment because someone is using his land without the right to do so.

2. Property Encroachment:

This occurs when someone extends their property into someone else’s property. For example, if Mrs. Meera is renovating her house and decides to build a fence that goes into her neighbor Mr. Kumar’s backyard, this is property encroachment. Even if Mrs. Meera thinks it’s just a small extension, it can create issues for Mr. Kumar, especially if he wants to use his backyard fully or sell his house in the future.

---

Penalty For Encroachment in India

Encroachment is not allowed by law. Under Section 447 of the IPC, anyone caught encroaching can face:

1. Up to three months in prison
2. A fine of up to Rs 550
3. Both

Dealing with Land Encroachment in a Friendly Way

To solve the encroachment problem, you can follow the Land Encroachment Act or try to resolve it together with the other person. Here are some friendly ways to handle land encroachment:

Talk with a Mediator:

Mediation is a simple and cost-effective way to fix the encroachment issue. Both you and the encroacher meet with a mediator and discuss the problem. Bring your property papers to explain your side. A mediator helps both sides reach an agreement without going to court.

Sell and Split the Money:

You can ask for help from an expert to sell the property. Then, both you and the encroacher can share the money from the sale. This way, both of you benefit and the problem is resolved.

Sell the Land to the Encroacher:

If the encroacher is interested, you can sell them the land they are using. This gives them legal ownership of the property and removes the encroachment issue.

Rent the Land:

If the encroacher only needs the land for a short time and doesn’t want to own it, you can rent it to them. They pay you money to use the land until everything is sorted out legally.

Adjust the Property Boundaries:

Sometimes, you and the encroacher can agree to change the property lines. This means both of you might give up a small part of your land to make the boundaries clear and fair for both.

Create a Written Agreement:

You and the encroacher can make a written agreement that explains how the land will be used. This agreement can include rules and conditions to prevent future conflicts.

---

How to Handle Land Encroachment Through the Law?

Different states in India have their own Land Encroachment Acts, which help property owners fight against encroachers. Here are some legal ways to handle land encroachment.

1. Get an Injunction:

• Permanent Injunction:
  A permanent injunction is a court order that completely stops the encroacher from using your land forever. You can ask the court to issue this order to ensure the encroacher never returns.

• Temporary Injunction:
  A temporary injunction is a court order that stops the encroacher from using your land for a certain period. This gives you time to sort out the issue while preventing further use of your property.

2. File a Case Under the Land Encroachment Act:

• As a property owner, you can file a case against the encroacher following Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the Land Encroachment Act.
  
• First, you submit an application to the court. The court will review your application and ask the encroacher to respond.
  
• After hearing both sides, the court will decide whether to accept or reject your application based on the evidence and arguments presented.

3. Ex-Parte Injunction:

• An ex-parte injunction is a court order given when only one party (you) responds to the case. The court does not wait for the encroacher to reply.

• This type of injunction can quickly stop the encroacher from using your land without waiting for their side of the story.

4. Send a Written Notice:

• Before going to court, you can send a written notice to the encroacher asking them to leave your property.
  
• If the encroacher does not leave within the given time, you can take the matter to court for further action.

---

Exploring Out-of-Court Settlements for Land Encroachment

Dealing with land encroachment through legal channels takes a long time and can be very complicated. It not only uses up a lot of time but also costs a lot of money. If possible, you should settle the matter out of court because it is usually a better option.

Documents Required to Prove You Own the Land

If you want to handle a land encroachment issue legally, you need to show that you own the land. Here are some important documents you should have:

1. Title deed:
   Proof of ownership with owner’s name, property location, and size.
   
2. Purchase agreement:
   Contract outlining sale terms, including price and payment.
   
3. Mutation Certificate:
   Official record updating land ownership.
   
4. Utility Bills:
   Bills in your name confirm property use.
   
5. Property Tax Receipts:
   Proof of tax payments supporting ownership.
   
6. Encumbrance Certificate:
   Ensures no legal or financial liabilities.

---

How to Protect Your Land from Encroachment?

Tip	Description
Assign a Power of Attorney (PoA)	If you live far away, give a trusted family member or friend a PoA to manage your property.
Install Fencing or Signs	Clearly mark your property with fences or signs to define boundaries.
Hire a Property Manager	Have someone regularly visit and watch over your land.
Use Security Measures	Set up a small concrete structure for a security guard or tenant and document everything properly.
Register Your Tenant	Verify and register tenants at the nearest police station if required by law.
Screen Tenants Carefully	Check tenants’ backgrounds thoroughly, especially if you are older.
Renew Lease Agreements	Update lease terms regularly to keep them current and clear.
Consider Selling if Necessary	If encroachers won’t leave, selling the land might be the best option.

---

Case Study: Haldwani Land Encroachment Case (2022)

The Haldwani Land Encroachment Case is a major issue in Uttarakhand, India. It involves the residents of Banbhoolpura, who live on land claimed by the Indian Railways. In December 2022, the Uttarakhand High Court ordered the removal of these encroachments. This affected about 50,000 people and 4,365 houses. The court acted after a public interest litigation (PIL) showed illegal buildings on government land.

Background

The conflict in Haldwani has been ongoing for years. In 2007, there were clashes when authorities tried to evict residents. Over the years, residents received eviction notices, but no one was removed successfully.

The situation got worse in December 2022 when the High Court ordered the eviction of Banbhoolpura residents. The residents protested, claiming they had rights to the land based on municipal records and tax payments.

Supreme Court Intervention

In January 2023, the Supreme Court stepped in and stayed the High Court’s eviction order. The Supreme Court said that both the residents’ rights and the railway’s needs must be considered.

Justice Surya Kant emphasized that the courts should treat the residents humanely. He noted that many families had lived on the land for decades and criticized the authorities for not handling the situation better over the years.

Recent Developments

On July 25, 2024, the Supreme Court ordered the Central and Uttarakhand governments to create a rehabilitation plan for those affected before any eviction.

Authorities must identify land needed for railway expansion and determine which families will be impacted within four weeks. This decision aims to ensure fair treatment for the residents while allowing railway projects to proceed.

---

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding encroachment in real estate is crucial for property owners, buyers, and investors alike. Encroachments can lead to legal disputes, affect property values, and complicate transactions if not identified and addressed early. Regular property surveys, clear boundary agreements, and proactive communication with neighbors are essential steps to prevent and resolve encroachment issues.

Credit Dharma’s home loan experts with decades of experience can help you shape the plan for your home loan. Connect with Credit Dharma today for a free consultation call.

---

Frequently Asked Questions